Politics of politics

By Azwihangwisi Mufamadi                                                          dscf3722.jpg                                             

Since Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) was implemented, South Africa has seen a rise in a number of millionaires. Most of these new millionaires are blacks already involved in the world of business. Although BEE was also meant to help people from the rural areas and the working class, none of these people have been empowered by BEE and half of them have no idea what it is about.

This is because most of the effort that has been made by the government to make people aware of BEE was made in the urban areas, and less in rural areas where it is needed most. A BEE deal that involves someone who is not among the small black elite is as rare as getting an apology from Robert Mugabe.

The money involved in a deal is either too little to be concerned about or the deal does not go through. BEE has only helped to create a tiny black elite while the lives of ordinary people are still the same as they were before the 1994 elections.

Among the black elite are Tokyo Sexwale at Mvelaphanda, Cyril Ramaphosa at Shanduka and Patrice  Motsepe at African Rainbow Minerals. All these people had well established businesses before they were empowered by BEE.

I thought BEE was meant to empower those who were previously disadvantaged, not people who already ad shares in other companies but I was obviously wrong because the BEE ‘top dogs’, Sexwale, Ramaphosa and Motsepe were well-established businessmen before BEE. Just how desperate is the government to make rich black people even richer? It seems to me that BEE is one of the government’s efforts to make a few rich people even richer.

It is not fair for other citizens of South Africa to empower known businesspeople while ordinary people are not getting a cent from BEE. Let us take an ordinary white person for example. Although he is as equally a South African citizen as Ramaphosa, he still does not qualify for BEE because he is white.

This is what the South African government calls ‘healing the inequalities of the past’. As far as I am  concerned you cannot heal inequalities by creating other inequalities. Despite being unfair to ordinary South Africans, BEE creates an unfair environment for competition in businesses for other people who compete with the BEE top dogs. They work hard to raise funds to grow their businesses while people like Sexwale, Motsepe and Ramaphosa just get it handed to them.

BEE is not that different from apartheid; it is like apartheid in reverse. The only difference between BEE and apartheid is that BEE is only benefiting a few while it also does not cost the majority a thing.


3 Responses to Politics of politics

  1. Joel says:

    That’s true BEE has failed dismally

  2. Vanzyl. says:

    It is actualy easy to spot the problem and diffucult to come with solutions. That’s true, but what can you do if they appoint you 2day to run BEE.

  3. Shivambu Caiphus says:

    Man I should really agree with you that the BEE strategy has really failed to live up to its initial objective of economically empowering the previously disadvantaged blacks.Hence one economics guru once famously stated that BEE really stand for ‘Black Elites Empowerment.You will be shocked to find that in the rural areas the BEE concept is a luxuty and does not even exist in the vocabulary of a poor rural man in the street.Most of the rural companies that have benefited from the BEE policy(if there are any),were already well-off even befire the concept BEE became a buzzword in the economics corridors.Recently the government has tried to revise its BEE strategy to BBBEE,and for me the government has n’t done much change than to add two more B’s to give it a nore fancy name,Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment.Another crisis that has faced the BEE policy is the problem of ”fronting”.For starters,fronting reers to when white-owned companies use top black executives like the Ramaphosas of this world as the faces of their companies in order to secure lucrative multi-million BEE deals.Interestingly,most of this BEE companies bear African names like Matodzi Resources,mm…Investment,in order to convince us that they are really ”black-owned” entities.Surprisingly the white owners of this companies don ‘t even know the meanings of this names.Truly speaking,BEE has just become a retirement home for former ANC heavyweights.So don’t be surprised to see JZ following in the footsteps of the likes of Ramaphosa ,Ngcuka,Maduna etc by joining the already-long list of the ANC-BEE if he fails to ascend to the highest office at the Union Buildings,come 2009. BEE should stop been an economic bee that stings poor South Africans.I wonder what will happen after all the ”blacks” would all have been BEE-ed.Dom’t be surprised if we soon have WABEE,that’s Whites-And-Blacks Economic Empowerment.After all this is South Africa,a country ”Alive with possibilities”.Watch the space….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: