From the Editor


By Bianca Silva

Last Sunday the Sunday Times front page read: “EDITOR, JOURNALIST TO BE ARRESTED.” This was for illegally possessing the health records of the health minister, Manto Tshabalala-Msimang. South Africa is a country that boasts democracy, freedom of speech and freedom of the press, yet it seems as though the government is reverting back to ways reminiscent of apartheid, the very opposite of what this country fought for. The Sunday Times had controversially published a story which reports that Tshabalala-Msimang allegedly drank large amounts of alcohol and shouted at hospital staff during her stay in hospital when she was undergoing a shoulder operation. She also allegedly covered up her alcoholic tendencies so that she could get a new liver which she needed because of suffering from hepatitis. Now, in the real world, alcoholics her age do not get new livers, in the same way that if you have suicidal tendencies you are not given preference for a new heart. For reporting and publishing this, editor, Mondli Makhanya and deputy managing editor and journalist, Jocelyn Maker, will almost certainly be arrested this week. Interestingly, government officials have not denied allegations. Instead they are pressing charges for reporting on something that is clearly in the public interest. About R400 000 of the public’s money has been wasted in purchasing newspaper advertisements in explaining that accessing someone else’s medical records is a crime. According to the Press Code of Professional Practice: “The public interest is the only test that justifies departure from the highest standards of journalism.” So what’s the point of freedom of the press if they can’t uncover that which affects the public? It appears that anyone who is critical of the ANC or the government is at risk of what Justice Malala refers to as president Mbeki’s “Stalinist learnings”. Just ask Ms Madlala-Routledge. In a recent Independent Online report, Roy Padayachee, a member of parliament commented to SAfm, said, “We want the media to stick close to the truth and we welcome a diversity of views. But the media has taken on a role of being an opposition to the ANC and the government.”Mbeki has created an atmosphere which makes it easy to paint anyone as “not a team player”. The media is the latest victim of the finger-pointing. Remember during apartheid the media critical of government was dubbed “South Africa’s worst enemy”. This raises an important question, what is Mbeki up to? Is he panicking because he realises he will soon be out of power? I would normally mention content but this edition I urge you to think about freedom of speech and freedom of the press. If you believe in this cause then stand up for Makhanya and Maker. If we want to be able to speak, publish and read freely then perhaps we need to support the press who report in the public interest. Watergate anyone?


3 Responses to From the Editor

  1. anonymus says:

    while i have never thought much of manto tshabalala as a minister especially for health two issues are key. first the manner in which the sundaytimes conducted their seeming ‘campaign’ against the health minister was childish, sad and unbecoming of quality press. secondly theft is theft, and a crime is a crime..freedom of expression should not be used as an excuse to clearly break the law and though should be given to the precedent that may be set if confidentiality of medical or even psychological records is not respected.

  2. Mawande says:

    i don’t think the two journalists should be arrested because, firstly, Msimang is not fired but there is evidence of her being a drunkard and a thief. the governanment in some way is trying to cover up for Manto by arresting the two journalists. They should not be arrested…i say

  3. Activate editor, Bianca Silva says:

    I thought this was an important issue to bring up because it calls into question whether public interest comes first or should someone who is a public figure not have his or her personal records put on display even if it may affect the public. Essentially it is a struggle between the private and public realm. There is another issue in that the article did not explicitly state how the Sunday Times got hold of those records. People who accuse the Sunday Times of stealing without knowing for sure, are making an assumption, much of the information journalists acquire is through sources, some who wish to remain anonymous for fear of getting into trouble. The editor and deputy editor and journalist have not been arrested, it seems public interest prevails. In my opinion, the issue to remember here is that the day the media can no longer serve public interest is the day we know that as a nation we are in grave danger. It will be as the media has called it, another “baked beans part two.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: