Response to Tri-Varsity Poll

I was appalled when I read yesterday’s edition of Activate. The front page had a poll “Would you go to Fort Hare for Tri-Varsity?” In my view it was quite improper to ask that question. It needed not to be asked in the first place. I view this as a race and class issue. Race in a sense that some among us still view blacks as incapable of hosting an event of such magnitude (this was an implicit argument expressed by the newspaper). We have seen manifestations of such stereotypes on this campus. Secondly, it is a class issue because it perpetuates stereotypes that, because Fort Hare is a historically black and impoverished institution, it is not good enough to host Tri-Varsity, that it doesn’t have infrastructural capacity to stage this event beyond it being predominantly black. It also attempts to shape the attitude of the student populace that going to Alice might be risky and that the event will be a definite failure. In fact this is a Tri-Varsity not a Bi-Varsity, if there is such a word. It can’t be that it is a Tri-Varsity and you exclude one institution on the basis of its economic status and racial composition. The student body deserves an explanation!

 

Diphapang Mofokeng

Head of Research and Policy Unit of SASCO at Rhodes University

 

Response from Editor:

You have brought up an interesting issue, one which Activate had not thought of. When we wrote that poll, we were simply looking to respond to the logistics surrounding this upcoming Tri-Varsity, mainly the issue of whether students could find enough accommodation and whether it would be a good idea for students to travel two hours in the dark back to Grahamstown. Firstly, let me say that in my capacity as editor of Activate I would like to see Fort Hare host this event; they have not yet been afforded the chance and I think they deserve it. However, just because they have an impoverished background this should not be seen as grounds to ignore logistical issues. If anything we should be talking about it more to ensure that we can sort out any potential problems and make Fort Hare hosting Tri-Varsity this year a reality. I would have hoped that our article on the front page was sufficient to contextualise the poll, however your response indicates otherwise. I hope this response clears things up. If race and class is still an issue with regards to this topic I do not think we should ignore these issues. As a student newspaper it is our duty to act as a platform for debate. The only way to resolve issues is to deal with them. Although the poll had not intended to look at class or race, it was placed to generate debate and it appears to have fulfilled that role.

Should anyone have any responses or comments please do not hesitate to email Activate at activate.editor@gmail.com

 

Bianca Silva

Editor

 

 

Advertisements

2 Responses to Response to Tri-Varsity Poll

  1. James says:

    Not everything is about black vs white Diphapang Mofokeng. The issues raised by activate is a relevent issue as many students will not be travelling to alice for tri varsity. At times we need to look at the plain facts. There will be substantially less students who are willing to travel to foret hare this year then there were travelling to PE last year….FACT!!!!! FACT 2: fort hare is not the worlds safest place, hebce the concerns from rhodes forcing Fort Hare to up the security as well has implement the use of CCTV cameras. I definetly wouldnt want my girlfriend, sister or any other girl for that matter walking even a tiny distance by herself in Alice. These are facts which need to be looked at, i dont think anyone really cares about the black/white issue which you have raised making your argument irrelivate and racial in itself.

  2. sarah says:

    Kindly edit heated responses from questionable readers before subjecting the rest of us to senseless drivel. Finally, James you make a mockery of your social prejudices with macho-paternal talk of your self-declared ‘caring’ attitude towards women. Diphapang Mofokeng, I agree with you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: